daniar
Senior Member
Plovdiv, Bulgaria
Bulgarian
- Jan 19, 2014
- #1
Hello native English speakers.
What does the phrase 'some scissors' mean? Is it grammatically correct? After reading this article in Yahoo!Answer http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/7215/is-pair-of-scissors-more-correct-than-scissors ,
My wife always gives me a hard time when I say scissors; she insists the only correct way to refer to that cutting device is "pair of scissors". Is "pair of scissors" more correct than "scissors"?
I understood it's used in informal writing when talking about only one pair of scissors. But can it be used for more than one pair of scissors or the appropriate phrase in this case is 'some pairs of scissors'?
Thank you in advance.
My question is about the meaning of the phrase 'some scissors ', not what the moderator has quoted.
<<Moderator note: I have inserted the text you referred to. We should not have to go to another website to understand your question and it is acceptable to quote up to 4 lines from your source>>
Last edited:
JulianStuart
Senior Member
Sonoma County CA
English (UK then US)
- Jan 19, 2014
- #2
"Some scissors" could mean either a pair of scissors or more than one pair of scissors, depending on the context. I often ask my wife to pass me the scissors. I might well say "I need some scissors". There is no need, most of the time, to add "pair of". It can be used for clarity as needed. There are some pairs of scissors on the table. That is clearly not ambiguous.
I have heard people say "a scissors". That sounds wrong to me. However, I know people who say "a scissor" when referring to "a pair of scissors" and there are enough who do this that some dictionaries have a separate entry for "scissor, noun" - it refers immediatey to the headword "scissors".
daniar
Senior Member
Plovdiv, Bulgaria
Bulgarian
- Jan 19, 2014
- #3
So if I were to say ' Would you give me some scissors, please? , it can either mean that I want one pair of scissors or two or three, or any number of pairs of scissors, can't it?
P
Parla
Member Emeritus
New York City
English - US
- Jan 19, 2014
- #4
Literally, yes, but usually one would assume that you're about to cut something and are requesting a single pair. It might be different if you're setting up a store display; then, you might be asking an assistant to hand you several pairs.
srk
Senior Member
South Bend, Indiana
English - US
- Jan 19, 2014
- #5
It is hard to imagine a situation in which Would you give me some scissors, please? would mean anything other than a single pair. If you wanted some other number of pairs of scissors, you would specify that number. If you just wanted a great many - say that you are distributing them to a group - you might say Would you give me several pairs of scissors, please? to obtain what you could carry. You'd have to think of a context in which how many pairs you received didn't matter and the person you were asking already knew that.
Cross-posted
You must log in or register to reply here.